Paris Hilton Paris Hilton

Star
Latest News
Biography
Fans
Hilton Family
FAQ and Facts
Poses
News Coverage
Encounter
Poems
Record Label
Enterprises


Multimedia
Gallery
Screensavers


Site
About
Links
Contact


Comments

    • Benji: Thank you PHS-admin for sharing and thank you Dawn for your kind words! So glad we are all still here (11...
    • Dawn: This is good !
    • Jen: Fall is too hectic a time to enjoy a big wedding. Burning Man is coming up, then Thanksgiving, and Chris will...
    • Dawn: I just bought her Rose Rush cologne and it smells so good! All her fragrances stay on for a long time Loves it !
    • Dawn: I just bought her Rose Rush cologne and it smells so good! Loves it! All her scents are delicious and stay on...
    • Jen: Cute clothes and very reasonably priced. I just ordered a swimsuit from her line.
    • Jen: FABULOUS !!!!!

  • Projects
    Fashion
    Music
    Movies
    TV Shows
    Books
    Commercials
    Nightclubs
    Games
    Charity Work


    Collection
    Fragrance
    Hair
    Watch
    Handbag
    Pet
    Clothing
    Footwear
    Creativity
    Sunglass
    False Eyelash
    Press-On Nail
    Nail Polish


    Stores
    Amazon
    eBay


    Products


    Paris Hilton Platinum Rush 3.4oz

    Platinum Rush 3.4 oz EDP Spray



    Paris Hilton Rose Rush 3.4oz

    Rose Rush 3.4 oz EDP Spray



    Paris Hilton Premium White Truffle Gold Sheet Mask

    Anti Aging Brightening Face Mask


    Hallmark wants court to dismiss Paris Hilton case

    Written by CourtHouseNews.com

    Lawyers for Hallmark Cards Inc. asked the full 9th Circuit to rehear a decision last month allowing Paris Hilton to move forward with a publicity-rights claim over the use of her image and catchphrase, “that’s hot,” in a birthday card.

    In a petition for rehearing filed Friday, Hallmark argued that the card qualifies for First Amendment protection as a spoof on the hotel heiress and her trademarked phrase.

    The card shows a cartoon waitress transposed with a photo of Hilton’s head. The cartoon Hilton tells a customer, “Don’t touch that, it’s hot?” The customer replies, “What’s hot?” and Hilton responds, “That’s hot.” The caption below the scene reads, “Paris’s First Day as a Waitress.”

    Hilton accused Hallmark of lifting the concept from her reality TV show, “The Simple Life,” in which she and friend Nicole Ritchie, who had a similarly privileged upbringing, do things an average person might do, such as work at a fast-food restaurant.

    A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit refused to dismiss the case in late August, saying Hilton “has at least some probability of prevailing on the merits” at trial.

    Hallmark attorney Lincoln Bandlow of Lathrop & Gage said the ruling departs with precedent by “incorrectly limiting and failing to properly apply” the transformative use test.

    “The Opinion’s conclusion is also contrary to well-established law under which parodies and spoofs of other works are regularly deemed transformative and protected by the First Amendment,” Bandlow wrote.

    He quoted Chief Judge Kozinski’s concern about courts giving celebrities a “right to keep people from mocking them or their work.”

    “The Opinion does exactly that,” Bandlow said, “in direct conflict with numerous decisions by this Court and others, and to the detriment of the fundamental right of free speech.”

    Share

    Comments

    Comment from scot
    Time: September 21, 2009, 8:55 pm

    Oh wow, I forgot about this. I wonder if Paris will actually do it. Hmm, I guess we’ll see.

    I probably should’ve just commented this on the earlier post but whatever, in a little paparazzi video Paris says her first single will be coming out around Christmas time which would make sense for a early 2010 release. But… we’ll see.

    Write a comment